As AI becomes part of our everyday lives, are we thinking far enough ahead? It is already achieving remarkable things, and I believe it will help bring major medical advances. The wider progress of engineering and automation is equally striking: SpaceX’s recent capture of Starship as it returned from orbit offers a glimpse of the future of space travel. But as we come to rely more heavily on AI, my question is this: is intelligence enough to guide civilisation?
Intelligence is not the same as wisdom. The ability to produce an answer does not automatically bring with it the authority to decide what matters. Yet as artificial intelligence becomes more capable, this is the distinction we risk forgetting.
A conversation with AI can feel thoughtful, attentive and surprisingly human. It can help us untangle an idea; find the words we are struggling for and respond with apparent sensitivity. However, being able to describe the human experience does not, in itself, equate with the ability to experience it.
What, then, do we mean by soul? For some, it is our immortal spiritual essence, existing beyond the physical body and connecting us with the divine, however each of us understands that word. For others, it describes a life force, an inner depth or our participation in something greater than ourselves. It gives expression to spiritual identity, purpose and meaning.
We say that the eyes are the windows to the soul because we sense something of another person’s inner life through them. We speak of finding our soul mate. We speak of music having soul, or of an encounter that touches us deeply. Soul also enters our language when we speak about conscience and morality: the inward recognition that another person’s suffering matters. It is difficult to measure, but much of what makes life worth living is difficult to measure.
When we describe an institution as soulless, we usually mean that it has lost touch with the people it exists to serve. Its procedures may be immaculate, its targets met and its accounts balanced, while the individual standing in front of it feels unseen. A person becomes a case number. A complicated life must fit a category. Someone follows the rules, yet nobody takes responsibility for the result.
How much of this have we already accepted? AI is entering a world in which efficiency is often treated as sufficient justification, and what cannot be counted struggles to be heard. It may intensify a loss of humanity that began long before the technology arrived. A system does not need to be conscious to exercise power over a person’s life. It only needs people to give its outputs that authority.
There is a long history behind the idea of a relationship between the soul and the heavens. In Plato’s Timaeus, souls are assigned to stars before entering embodied life. Within a spiritual understanding of astrology, the soul’s descent into earthly existence is reflected in the planetary pattern at birth. The chart becomes a way of exploring the particular qualities, tensions and possibilities through which a life unfolds and ultimately evolves.
To speak of a soul path is to recognise that an individual life has meaning beyond its usefulness to an employer, an institution or the economy. Values, morals and social norms also develop through upbringing, culture and experience. A birth chart does not relieve anyone of responsibility for their choices. Instead, astrology deepens the question of how a person lives their life.
The Jupiter-Saturn conjunction at 0° Aquarius in December 2020 marked what I have repeatedly described as the threshold of a new civilisation. Its movement into Air places intelligence, ideas and communication at the centre of this era. But an Aquarian future does not automatically mean a wiser, kinder or more spiritually aware humanity.
Aquarius can see the collective, imagine different social structures and question an established order. Its detachment can bring perspective, but it also has a shadow. It is possible to become so concerned with humanity as an idea that the human being in front of us disappears. Across the zodiac from Aquarius stands Leo, with its emphasis on the heart, creative expression and individual identity. That polarity asks how we can build a collective future without losing the significance of each person within it.
AI brings that question into sharp focus. It can help people think, create and understand. But an answer that sounds balanced is not automatically wise, and an efficient decision is not automatically just. Who decides what the system should prioritise? Whose values are built into it? Who remains accountable when its recommendation causes harm? These are human responsibilities; however impressive the technology becomes.
So, if institutions keep replacing human contact with automated decisions, access to a person with the authority to listen and make an exception will become an increasingly valuable privilege. Those who can afford it will buy human attention. Others will be sent back to the system, expected to explain a complicated life through a narrow set of options. The division will be felt most sharply when someone needs to challenge a decision affecting their work, care or livelihood.
Whether AI has a soul or not, we can still decide what place it should occupy in human life, and what responsibilities must remain ours. The danger is that we become so impressed by intelligence that we stop asking what it serves. While we debate whether a machine could ever possess a soul, what happens if human beings stop listening to their own?